<h3 class='c001'>CHAPTER XVII</h3></div>
<div class='lg-container-b c009'>
<div class='linegroup'>
<div class='group'>
<div class='line'>Affections, Instincts, Principles, and Powers,</div>
<div class='line'>Impulse and Reason, Freedom and Control—</div>
<div class='line'>So men, unravelling God’s harmonious whole,</div>
<div class='line'>Rend in a thousand shreds this life of ours.</div>
<div class='line'>Vain labour! Deep and broad, where none may see,</div>
<div class='line'>Spring the foundations of that shadowy throne</div>
<div class='line'>Where man’s one nature, queen-like, sits alone,</div>
<div class='line'>Centred in a majestic unity.</div>
<div class='line in34'>—<span class='sc'>Matthew Arnold.</span></div>
</div></div>
</div>
<p class='c010'>To some minds there is nothing more pathetic in
human experience than the patient resignation with
which average men and women accommodate themselves
to the most disastrous and distorting of griefs
and disappointments, nothing more amazing than their
power to endure. If something of the brute nature is
in us all, it is not always and altogether the animalhood
of greed or of ferocity, but far more commonly the
mute, uncomprehending submission of sheep and oxen.
Though the futility of revolt is so apparent, the infrequency
of it in human lives does not cease to surprise.
The modern Rachel mourns for her children, and will
not be comforted, but she goes about the streets in conventional
mourning, orders her house with decent regularity,
and probably, in the end, goes abroad for a time,
and returning, enters with apparent cheerfulness into the
social round. The modern Guelph or Ghibelline, banished
from the political or intellectual activities which
made life to him, finds readily that raving against time
and fate is no longer good form, reads his daily paper
<span class='pageno' id='Page_158'>158</span>with unabated interest, and enjoys a good dinner with
appetite unimpaired. Very probably the man’s and the
woman’s heart is broken in each instance, but what
then? Life goes on, and the resiliency of the mainspring
in a well-adjusted piece of human mechanism
may be usually guaranteed, with safety, to last a lifetime.</p>
<p class='c011'>In a year after her marriage Anna Burgess was diligently
at work along the conventional lines of activity of
her day for religious young women at home,—writing
missionary reports, distributing literature, collecting dues.
She saw nothing better to do. Her own private and
innermost relation to God, it was true, had been dislocated,
but the heathen remained to be saved.</p>
<p class='c011'>One morning, Keith being away from home, Anna
came into Madam Burgess’s sitting room, her cheeks
slightly flushed, her eyes shining, a letter in hand.</p>
<p class='c011'>“May I read you this?” she asked eagerly; “I have
been invited to give an address at the foreign missionary
conference next month in H——. What if I could!
I should be so glad.” Her eyes told the new and eager
hope which this summons had stirred within her.</p>
<p class='c011'>An added degree of frost settled upon her mother-in-law’s
face.</p>
<p class='c011'>“You can hardly mean, Anna,” she said, “that you
would be willing to speak in public?”</p>
<p class='c011'>“But our missionaries do, and sometimes others,”
Anna replied anxiously.</p>
<p class='c011'>“The case of missionaries is, of course, entirely exceptional;
and they should never be heard, in my opinion,
before mixed audiences. As for other women making
spectacles of themselves, it would seem to be enough to
remind you, Anna, of the words of the Apostle Paul on
<span class='pageno' id='Page_159'>159</span>that subject. You would hardly attempt, I think, to
explain them away.”</p>
<p class='c011'>Anna was silent.</p>
<p class='c011'>“A woman who has a noble Christian husband, my
dear,” continued Madam Burgess, more gently, feeling
her case now won, “as you have, who is already at work
in this very field of labour, has no occasion to leave the
sacred shelter of her own home, and lift up her voice
and exhibit her person in public gatherings.”</p>
<p class='c011'>“Keith always said that I might still have a chance
to do a little work in this way; I am sure he approved,”
and Anna’s low voice faltered, her heart full just then of
the memory of those first days of their common sorrow.</p>
<p class='c011'>“You have a very indulgent husband, and it is not
strange if, in the first fond days of your married life, he
may have unwisely yielded to some mistaken sense of
duty on your part, and apparently committed himself to
a purpose which he would later realize to be impracticable.
Understand me clearly, my dear,” and the term
of endearment sounded, from Madam Burgess’s lips, as
sharp as the point of an icicle, “my son’s wife can never,
without flying in the face of all her holiest obligations,
both to God and man, present herself before an audience
of people as a public speaker. A woman who does this
violates the very law of her being, she ceases to be
womanly, ceases to be modest, and loses all that feminine
delicacy which is woman’s chief ornament.”</p>
<p class='c011'>The finality of these remarks clearly perceived, Anna
rose from her chair, and left the room in silence. She
never returned to the subject, but simply buried in her
heart one more high hope of service.</p>
<p class='c011'>This was the first time that Anna’s inexperience and
young ardour had joined direct issue with Madam Burgess’s
<span class='pageno' id='Page_160'>160</span>social creed. For a while everything had gone so
smoothly that Anna’s first sense of disparity had been
soothed to rest; all things being new, she had failed to
see the full significance of certain limitations which
hedged her in. Little by little she learned this, and
learned the inevitable submission. She never appealed
to Keith from his mother, controlled by a sense of the
essential ugliness and vulgarity of a domestic situation
in which the different elements are working and interworking
at variance with each other. Furthermore, she
learned very soon that, however sympathetic and gentle
Keith might show himself toward her, he would, in
the end, range himself on his mother’s side of every
question.</p>
<p class='c011'>Stratagem and indirection were alike alien to Anna’s
nature and habit, but she inevitably learned, in process
of time and experience, to avoid leading Madam Burgess
to a declaration of definite positions, while she sought to
enlist her husband’s sympathies in her own undertakings
before his mother was made acquainted with them. Any
plan which was brought before her by her son was comparatively
acceptable to the elder woman. Thus wisely
ordering her goings as women learn to do, Anna succeeded
in reaching a fair degree of independence and at the same
time a harmonious outward order. Her sacrifices and
disappointments, the gradual paring down of her larger
hopes and the dimming of her finer aspirations, she kept
to herself.</p>
<p class='c011'>Pierce Everett, the young artist who had spoken of
Anna’s fitness for a model of a saint, had carried out
his purpose, and had formally requested her to pose for
him. With the cordial approval of both Madam Burgess
and Keith, Anna had consented, and late in the winter
<span class='pageno' id='Page_161'>161</span>the sittings began in Everett’s studio, which was in his
father’s house. Madam Burgess brought Anna to the
house for the first sitting. They were received by the
mother of the artist, an intimate friend of Madam Burgess,
and the older ladies then laughingly gave Anna over into
Everett’s hands while they enjoyed a discussion of certain
benevolent committee matters.</p>
<p class='c011'>In the studio a little talk ensued regarding the projected
sittings, and various considerations involved in
them. These matters understood, Anna said composedly:—</p>
<p class='c011'>“I am ready, Mr. Everett, if you will tell me just
what you wish. I do not even know for what I am to
be painted.”</p>
<p class='c011'>“And you will not object, Mrs. Burgess,” said
Everett, quickly, “if I do not tell you now? It is in
a character which could not, I am sure, displease you,
but I think it would be decidedly better that we should
not discuss it, and that you should have no definite
thought of it. Is this satisfactory to you?”</p>
<p class='c011'>“Entirely so.”</p>
<p class='c011'>“Very well.”</p>
<p class='c011'>Immediately upon this Everett took his place at the
easel and began a first rapid sketch of Anna’s head. He
was a slight fellow, below the medium height, with a
delicate, almost transparent face, a red Vandyke beard,
and large and brilliant brown eyes. Quick and nervous
in speech and gesture, he had the clear-cut precision of a
man who knows both his means and his end.</p>
<p class='c011'>Anna thought him very interesting.</p>
<p class='c011'>At the second sitting their talk chanced to turn upon
the relation of the ideals of men and women to their
practical lives, and Everett told Anna the old story of
<span class='pageno' id='Page_162'>162</span>Carcassonne, which was new to her. The train of
thought thus suggested soon absorbed her, so that she
forgot him and what he was doing. The sacred hope
of her own life, yet unfulfilled, still centring in the hope
of her father, the ever receding purpose of which she
never spoke, cast its powerful influence upon her.</p>
<p class='c011'>For half an hour neither spoke. Then Everett’s
friend, Professor Ward, came into the room in familiar
fashion, and the two men talked of many things.</p>
<p class='c011'>When Anna left Nathan Ward said, looking over his
friend’s shoulder:—</p>
<p class='c011'>“If you can keep that look, you will make a great
picture.” Then he added, “But don’t fail to get her
hands. They have the same expression.”</p>
<p class='c011'>After that it became an habitual thing for Ward to
drop into the studio at these sittings. It never occurred
to Anna that her presence had anything to do with his
coming. She supposed he had always come. He talked
very little with her, but she liked to listen to his talk
with Everett. It was distinctly novel to her—light,
rambling, touch-and-go, and yet full of underlying
thought and suggestion. Anna had known few men
at best, none of the order to which these two belonged,
men conversant with art and literature, music and
poetry, and modern life on all its sides. Much that
they said puzzled and perplexed her, but she found an
eager enjoyment in it.</p>
<p class='c011'>Then one day Professor Ward said to her, apropos of
Shelley, of whom they had been speaking:—</p>
<p class='c011'>“You do not join in this discussion, Mrs. Burgess.
I am quite sure you could give us opinions much wiser
than ours.”</p>
<p class='c011'>Anna’s colour deepened as she answered:—</p>
<p class='c011'><span class='pageno' id='Page_163'>163</span>“I have not read Shelley in a great many years. Indeed,
I know nothing of literature.”</p>
<p class='c011'>There was a little silence; Anna hesitated, half
inclined to say a word in explanation of a fact which
she plainly saw the two men found very surprising, but
finally, finding the explanation too personal and too serious,
remained silent.</p>
<p class='c011'>As she started to walk home from the Everett’s, Professor
Ward joined her, asking to walk with her. He
was a man of forty, with a wife and a flock of little
children. Anna knew the family slightly, but pleasantly.</p>
<p class='c011'>“Mrs. Burgess,” the professor began, as they walked
down the quiet street, “I do not want to intrude or to
be found inquisitive, but I am so puzzled by what you
said a little while ago that I really wish you felt inclined
to enlighten me. I know you never speak with the
exaggeration and inaccuracy which is so much the habit
of young ladies, and so I accept what you said as to your
ignorance of literature as sober truth. But you are a
well-educated woman. How can it be?”</p>
<p class='c011'>Anna was almost glad of a chance to explain. She
was facing many new questions in these days, and she
felt the need of light. She answered therefore at once,
with frankness:—</p>
<p class='c011'>“I deliberately gave up study on all these lines when
I became a Christian. I supposed them to be contrary
to the absolute consecration of my life to God.”</p>
<p class='c011'>Professor Ward looked perplexed.</p>
<p class='c011'>“You cannot understand,” Anna said timidly. “I
have felt since I have been in Fulham as if the language
of my religious life in those days would be an unknown
tongue here. I see that I am right. To you, Professor
Ward, I am sure such a sense of duty as I speak of is
<span class='pageno' id='Page_164'>164</span>unintelligible, but I can still say it was sincere. And it
was not an easy sacrifice to make, for I had already
grown fond of poetry, and longed to know more in a
way I could never express.”</p>
<p class='c011'>“I see,” said her companion, gravely; “you felt that
the study of the work of men like most of our poets,
whose religious positions were vague and not formulated
according to our creeds, was likely to act unfavourably
upon your spiritual life and experience.”</p>
<p class='c011'>“Yes. To divide my heart, to dim my sense of a
one, single aim in life.”</p>
<p class='c011'>“And that aim?”</p>
<p class='c011'>“To serve God directly in every thought and word.
That, and to try to save the souls of the lost.”</p>
<p class='c011'>Professor Ward had no key to the profound sadness
with which Anna spoke, but he watched her face with
earnest interest. She spoke with the unconsciousness
of absolute sincerity. He was reflecting, however, on
how much easier life might be if one could sustain, undisturbed,
such bare simplicity of conception of human
relations.</p>
<p class='c011'>“And so,” he said slowly, “you were going to
prune away every instinct, every faculty of your nature
which did not serve the immediate purpose of
furthering what men call sometimes ‘the cause of religion,’
and know and feel and be one thing only?”</p>
<p class='c011'>Anna bent her head in assent.</p>
<p class='c011'>“That is precisely what men and women do who
seek monastic life.”</p>
<p class='c011'>Anna looked up at Professor Ward in quick surprise
and instinctive protest.</p>
<p class='c011'>“Yes,” he said, with emphasis, “it was just as noble
and just as cowardly, just as weak and just as strong, as
<span class='pageno' id='Page_165'>165</span>the impulses which make monks and nuns. It is what
people do who are afraid of life, who do not dare to
encounter the whole of it, who have not reached the
highest faith in either God or man.”</p>
<p class='c011'>“Then you think such a resolution, such a scheme
of life, produces weak natures, not strong ones?” asked
Anna, looking up with her honest, steadfast gaze into
his eyes.</p>
<p class='c011'>“I should say narrow natures, and yet I fear I ought
to say weak ones too. Mrs. Burgess, do you not see
yourself the weakness, the narrowness, of the position?
It is what might be called the department system of
human life,” and Professor Ward, with rapid gestures,
indicated the drawing of sharp lines. “It is as if you
said to your ego, your soul—yourself—whatever,—Go
to now, this department of your life is religious; it
sings hymns, reads a collection of sacred writings at regular
hours, prays, gives away money to build churches,
and performs various other exercises definitely stamped
as godly. This other department loves nature, exults in
beauty, pours itself into poetic thought, rejoices in music,
expresses itself in art: but all this is secular, pagan—all
men may have this in common who have not accepted
my particular conception of the divine nature and its
dealings with men; consequently all this is to be cut off—effaced,
fought with to the death. Am I right?”</p>
<p class='c011'>Anna nodded, her face very grave, her breath quickened.</p>
<p class='c011'>“Does that seem to you a reasonable or even a noble
conception? There was nobleness, I grant you, in the
struggle, just as there was in the fortitude of the Spartans;
but who feels now a desire to imitate that sheer,
barbaric effacing of human feeling? No, no. That
<span class='pageno' id='Page_166'>166</span>day has passed. We can begin to see life whole to-day;
we can see God in nature, in poetry, in beauty, in ugliness
even. He is all and in all. All things are ours
and we are God’s! I wish I could make this clear to
you.”</p>
<p class='c011'>“You have, in part,” said Anna, simply.</p>
<p class='c011'>“No way, however tortuous, by which men have
groped after God can be indifferent to us, if we have the
right sense of humanity. Trust yourself, Mrs. Burgess;
trust the human heart throughout the ages. Believe me,
with all the drawbacks, all the falls, and all the blunders,
it has been an honest heart and is worthy of reverence
and devout study. ‘Trust God: see all, nor be
afraid.’”</p>
<p class='c011'>“I have seen only one side of life, one conception of
human nature.”</p>
<p class='c011'>“That, at least, was a high and lofty one. For stern
heroism of thought, commend me to that old New England
Calvinism in which I see you were nurtured. It
was fine; I glory in it, just as I glory in heroism everywhere,
builded up on however mistaken a foundation.
The worst of it, however, is that it completely deceives
the human heart as to itself. It is terrible in its power
to mislead. The elect are not as elect by half as they
suppose. Calvin himself helped to burn Servetus, which
was not really fine of him, you know. But I have said
enough. I hope I have not wounded you?”</p>
<p class='c011'>“I do not think so,” said Anna, smiling faintly, “but
I am amazed beyond everything. All that you say is
so new.”</p>
<p class='c011'>They had reached Professor Ward’s house, which
was very near that of Madam Burgess.</p>
<p class='c011'>“I wish you would come in a moment,” said Ward,
<span class='pageno' id='Page_167'>167</span>very gently; “you know my wife always likes to see
you, and I want to show you some books in which I
think you would be interested.”</p>
<p class='c011'>Without reply, Anna passed through the gate which
he held open for her, and they entered the house together.
Mrs. Ward met them, and they all went into
the professor’s study.</p>
<p class='c011'>In a few moments Anna was lost in the realm of
books so long self-closed to her experience. She sat at
his desk, and Ward handed her and heaped about her
rare and beautiful volumes until she became bewildered
with the sense of intellectual richness and complexity.
She looked up at last, as he bent over her, turning the
leaves of a beautiful old Italian edition of Dante’s
“Commedia,” and, with a smile beneath which her lips
trembled, she asked, like a child:—</p>
<p class='c011'>“Tell me truly, is all this for me, righteously,
safely?”</p>
<p class='c011'>“Did I not tell you?” he asked gently. “‘All things
are yours, and you are Christ’s, and Christ is God’s.’”</p>
<p class='c011'>With that day Anna returned to the long-sealed books
of her father’s love and her own. She read and studied
under Professor Ward’s guidance and direction, steadily
and with eager delight. She did this with no further
misgiving or doubt. He had succeeded in satisfying her
conscience, and she moved joyfully along the clear lines
of her inherited intellectual choice.</p>
<p class='c011'>As for her father and the example of renunciation he
had given her, her heart was at rest. That which was
perfect being come for him, was not that which had
been in part done away?</p>
<div>
<span class='pageno' id='Page_168'>168</span>
<div style="break-after:column;"></div><br />