<SPAN name="startofbook"></SPAN>
<h1>THE MAN <br/>WHO FELL THROUGH <br/>THE EARTH</h1>
<h2><span class="small">BY</span>
<br/><span class="large">CAROLYN WELLS</span></h2>
<h2 id="c1"><span class="small">CHAPTER I</span> <br/>Moving Shadow-Shapes</h2>
<p>One of the occasions when I experienced
“that grand and glorious feeling” was
when my law business had achieved proportions
that justified my removal from my old
office to new and more commodious quarters. I
selected a somewhat pretentious building on Madison
Avenue between Thirtieth and Fortieth Streets,
and it was a red-letter day for me when I moved
into my pleasant rooms on its top floor.</p>
<p>The Puritan Trust Company occupied all of the
ground floor and there were also some of the private
offices of that institution on the top floor, as
well as a few offices to be let.</p>
<p>My rooms were well located and delightfully
light, and I furnished them with care, selecting
chairs and desks of a dignified type, and rugs of
appropriately quiet coloring. I also selected my
stenographer with care, and Norah MacCormack
was a red-haired piece of perfection. If she had
a weakness, it was for reading detective stories, but
I condoned that, for in my hammocky moods I,
too, dipped into the tangled-web school of fiction.</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_12">[12]</div>
<p>And, without undue conceit, I felt that I could
give most specimens of the genus Sherlock cards
and spades and beat them at their own game of
deduction. I practiced it on Norah sometimes.
She would bring me a veil or glove of some friend
of hers, and I would try to deduce the friend’s
traits of character. My successes and failures were
about fifty-fifty, but Norah thought I improved
with practice, and, anyway, it exercised my intelligence.</p>
<p>I had failed to pass examination for the army,
because of a defect, negligible, it seemed to me, in
my eyesight. I was deeply disappointed, but as the
law of compensation is usually in force, I unexpectedly
proved to be of some use to my Government
after all.</p>
<p class="tb">Across the hall from me was the private office
of Amos Gately, the President of the Puritan Trust
Company, and a man of city-wide reputation. I
didn’t know the great financier personally, but
everyone knew of him, and his name was a
synonym for all that is sound, honorable, and
philanthropic in the money mart. He was of that
frequently seen type, with the silver gray hair that
so becomingly accompanies deep-set dark eyes.</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_13">[13]</div>
<p>And yet, I had never seen Mr. Gately himself.
My knowledge of him was gained from his frequent
portraiture in the papers or in an occasional
magazine. And I had gathered, in a vague way,
that he was a connoisseur of the fine arts, and that
his offices, as well as his home, were palatial in
their appointments.</p>
<p>I may as well admit, therefore, that going in
and out of my own rooms I often looked toward
his door, in hopes that I might get a glimpse, at
least, of the treasures within. But so far I had
not done so.</p>
<p>To be sure, I had only occupied my own suite
about a week and then again Mr. Gately was not
always in his private offices during business hours.
Doubtless, much of the time he was down in the
banking rooms.</p>
<p>There was a yellow-haired stenographer, who
wore her hair in ear-muffs, and who was, I should
say, addicted to the vanity-case. This young person,
Norah had informed me, was Jenny Boyd.</p>
<p>And that sums up the whole of my intimate
knowledge of Amos Gately—until the day of the
black snow squall!</p>
<p>I daresay my prehistoric ancestors were sun-worshipers.
At any rate, I am perfectly happy
when the sun shines, and utterly miserable on a
gloomy day. Of course, after sunset, I don’t care,
but days when artificial light must be used, I get
fidgety and am positively unable to concentrate on
any important line of thought.</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_14">[14]</div>
<p>And so, when Norah snapped on her green-shaded
desk light in mid-afternoon, I impulsively
jumped up to go home. I could stand electrically
lighted rooms better in my diggings than in the
work-compelling atmosphere of my office.</p>
<p>“Finish that bit of work,” I told my competent
assistant, “and then go home yourself. I’m going
now.”</p>
<p>“But it’s only three o’clock, Mr. Brice,” and
Norah’s gray eyes looked up from the clicking
keys.</p>
<p>“I know it, but a snow storm is brewing,—and
Lord knows there’s snow enough in town now!”</p>
<p>“There is so! I’m thinking they won’t get the
black mountains out of the side streets before
Fourth of July,—and the poor White Wings working
themselves to death!”</p>
<p>“Statistics haven’t yet proved that cause of
death prevalent among snow-shovelers,” I returned,
“but I’m pretty sure there’s more chance for it
coming to them!”</p>
<p>I hate snow. For the ocular defect that kept me
out of the army is corrected by not altogether unbecoming
glasses, but when these are moistened or
misted by falling snow, I am greatly incommoded.
So I determined to reach home, if possible, before
the squall which was so indubitably imminent.</p>
<p>I snugged into my overcoat, and jammed my hat
well down on my head, for the wind was already
blowing a gale.</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_15">[15]</div>
<p>“Get away soon, Norah,” I said, as I opened
the door into the hall, “and if it proves a blizzard
you needn’t show up tomorrow.”</p>
<p>“Oh, I’ll be here, Mr. Brice,” she returned, in
her cheery way, and resumed her clicking.</p>
<p class="tb">The offices of Mr. Gately, opposite mine, had
three doors to the hall, meaning, I assumed, three
rooms in his suite.</p>
<p>My own door was exactly opposite the middle
one of the three. On that was the number two.
To its left was number one, and to its right, number
three.</p>
<p>Each of these three doors had an upper panel
of thick, clouded glass, and, as the hall was not
yet lighted and Mr. Gately’s rooms were, I could
see quite plainly the shadows of two heads on the
middle door,—the door numbered two.</p>
<p>Perhaps I am unduly curious, perhaps it was
merely a natural interest, but I stood still a moment,
outside my own door, and watched the two
shadowed heads.</p>
<p>The rippled clouding of the glass made their outlines
somewhat vague, but I could distinguish the
fine, thick mane of Amos Gately, as I had so often
seen it pictured. The other was merely a human
shadow with no striking characteristics.</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_16">[16]</div>
<p>It was evident their interview was not amicable.
I heard a loud, explosive “No!” from one or
other of them, and then both figures rose and
there was a hand-to-hand struggle. Their voices
indicated a desperate quarrel, though no words
were distinguishable.</p>
<p>And then, as I looked, the shadows blurred into
one another,—swayed,—separated, and then a pistol
shot rang out, followed immediately by a
woman’s shrill scream.</p>
<p>Impulsively I sprang across the hall, and turned
the knob of door number two,—the one opposite
my own door, and the one through which I had
seen the shadowed actions.</p>
<p>But the door would not open.</p>
<p>I hesitated only an instant and then hurried to
the door next on the right, number three.</p>
<p>This, too, was fastened on the inside, so I ran
back to the only other door, number one,—to the
left of the middle door.</p>
<p>This door opened at my touch, and I found
myself in the first of Amos Gately’s magnificent
rooms.</p>
<p>Beyond one quick, admiring glance, I paid no
attention to the beautiful appointments, and I
opened the communicating door into the next or
middle room.</p>
<p>This, like the first, contained no human being,
but it was filled with the smoke and the odor of
a recently fired pistol.</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_17">[17]</div>
<p>I looked around, aghast. This was the room
where the altercation had taken place, where two
men had grappled, where a pistol had been fired,
and moreover, where a woman had screamed.
Where were these people?</p>
<p>In the next room, of course, I reasoned.</p>
<p>With eager curiosity, I went on into the third
room. It was empty.</p>
<p>And that was all the rooms of the suite.</p>
<p>Where were the people I had seen and heard?
That is, I had seen their shadows on the glass door,
and human shadows cannot appear without people
to cast them. Where were the men who had
fought? Where was the woman who had screamed?
And who were they?</p>
<p class="tb">Dazed, I went back through the rooms. Their
several uses were clear enough. Number one was
the entrance office. There was an attendant’s desk,
a typewriter, reception chairs, and all the effects of
the first stage of an interview with the great man.</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_18">[18]</div>
<p>The second office, beyond a doubt, was Mr.
Gately’s sanctum. A stunning mahogany table-desk
was in the middle of the floor, and a large,
unusually fine swivel-chair stood behind it. On the
desk, things were somewhat disordered. The telephone
was upset, the papers pushed into an untidy
heap, a pen-tray overturned, and a chair opposite
the big desk chair lay over on its side, as if Mr.
Gately’s visitor had risen hurriedly. The last
room, number three, was, clearly, the very holy of
holies. Surely, only the most important or most
beloved guests were received in here. It was furnished
as richly as a royal salon, yet all in most
perfect taste and quiet harmony. The general coloring
of draperies and upholstery was soft blue, and
splendid pictures hung on the wall. Also, there
was a huge war map of Europe, and indicative pins
stuck in it proved Mr. Gately’s intense interest in
the progress of events over there.</p>
<p>But though tempted to feast my eyes on the art
treasures all about, I eagerly pursued my quest for
the vanished human beings I sought.</p>
<p>There was no one in any of these three rooms,
and I could see no exit, save into the hall from
which I had entered. I looked into three or four
cupboards, but they were full of books and papers,
and no sign of a hidden human being, alive or
dead, could I find.</p>
<p>Perhaps the strangeness of it all blunted my
efficiency. I had always flattered myself that I
was at my best in an emergency, but all previous
emergencies in which I had found myself were
trivial and unimportant compared with this.</p>
<p>I felt as if I had been at a moving picture show.
I had seen, as on the screen, a man shot, perhaps
killed, and now all the actors had vanished as completely
as they do when the movie is over.</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_19">[19]</div>
<p>Then, for I am not entirely devoid of conscience,
it occurred to me that I had a duty,—that it was
incumbent upon me to report to somebody. I
thought of the police, but was it right to call them
when I had so vague a report to make? What
could I tell them? That I had seen shadows fighting?
Heard a woman scream? Smelled smoke?
Heard the report of a pistol? A whimsical thought
came that the report of the pistol was the only
definite report I could swear to!</p>
<p>Yet the whole scene was definite enough to me.</p>
<p>I had seen two men fighting,—shadows, to be
sure, but shadows of real men. I had heard their
voices raised in dissension of some sort, I had seen
a scuffle and had heard a shot, of which I had
afterward smelled the smoke, and,—most incriminating
of all,—I had heard a woman’s scream. A
scream, too, of terror, as for her life!</p>
<p>And then, I had immediately entered these
rooms, and I had found them empty of all human
presence, but with the smoke still hanging low, to
prove my observations had been real, and no figment
of my imagination.</p>
<p>I believed I had latent detective ability. Well,
surely here was a chance to exercise it!</p>
<p>What more bewildering mystery could be desired
than to witness a shooting, and, breaking in
upon the scene, to find no victim, no criminal, and
no weapon!</p>
<p>I hunted for the pistol, but found no more trace
of that than of the hand that had fired it.</p>
<p>My brain felt queer; I said to myself, over and
over, “a fight, a shot, a scream! No victim, no
criminal, no weapon!”</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_20">[20]</div>
<p>I looked out in the hall again. I had already
looked out two or three times, but I had seen no
one. However, I didn’t suppose the villain and his
victim had gone down by the elevator or by the
stairway.</p>
<p>But where were they? And where was the
woman who had screamed?</p>
<p>Perhaps it was she who had been shot. Why
did I assume that Mr. Gately was the victim?
Could not he have been the criminal?</p>
<p>The thought of Amos Gately in the rôle of murderer
was a little too absurd! Still, the whole
situation was absurd.</p>
<p>For me, Tom Brice, to be involved in this
baffling mystery was the height of all that was
incredible!</p>
<p>And yet, was I involved? I had only to walk
out and go home to be out of it all. No one had
seen me and no one could know I had been there.</p>
<p>And then something sinister overcame me. A
kind of cold dread of the whole affair; an uncanny
feeling that I was drawn into a fearful web of
circumstances from which I could not honorably
escape, if, indeed, I could escape at all. The three
Gately rooms, though lighted, felt dark and eerie.
I glanced out of a window. The sky was almost
black and scattering snowflakes were falling. I
realized, too, that though the place was lighted,
the fixtures were those great alabaster bowls, and,
as they hung from the ceiling, they seemed to give
out a ghostly radiance that emphasized the strange
silence.</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_21">[21]</div>
<p>For, in my increasingly nervous state, the silence
was intensified and it seemed the silence of death,—not
the mere quiet of an empty room.</p>
<p>I pulled myself together, for I had not lost all
sense of my duty. I <i>must</i> do something, I told
myself, sternly,—but what?</p>
<p>My hand crept toward the telephone that lay,
turned over on its side, on Mr. Gately’s desk.</p>
<p>But I drew back quickly, not so much because of
a disinclination to touch the thing that had perhaps
figured in a tragedy but because of a dim
instinct of leaving everything untouched as a possible
clew.</p>
<p>Clew! The very word helped restore my
equilibrium. There had been a crime of some
sort,—at least, there had been a shooting, and I
had been an eye-witness, even if my eyes had seen
only shadows.</p>
<p>My rôle, then, was an important one. My duty
was to tell what I had seen and render any assistance
I could. But I wouldn’t use that telephone.
It must be out of order, anyway, or the operator
downstairs would be looking after it. I would go
back to my own office and call up somebody. As
I crossed the hall, I was still debating whether that
somebody would better be the police or the bank
people downstairs. The latter, I decided, for it was
their place to look after their president, not mine.</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_22">[22]</div>
<p>I found Norah putting on her hat. The sight
of her shrewd gray eyes and intelligent face caused
an outburst of confidence, and I told her the whole
story as fast as I could rattle it out.</p>
<p>“Oh, Mr. Brice,” she exclaimed, her eyes wide
with excitement, “let me go over there! May I?”</p>
<p>“Wait a minute, Norah: I think I ought to speak
to the bank people. I think I’ll telephone down
and ask if Mr. Gately is down there. You know
it may not have been Mr. Gately at all, whose
shadow I saw——”</p>
<p>“Ooh, yes, it was! You couldn’t mistake his
head, and, too, who else would be in there?
Please, Mr. Brice, wait just a minute before you
telephone,—let me take one look round,—you don’t
want to make a—to look foolish, you know.”</p>
<p>She had so nearly warned me against making a
fool of myself, that I took the hint, and I followed
her across the hall.</p>
<p>She went in quickly at the door of room number
one. One glance around it and she said, “This is
the first office, you see: callers come here, the secretary
or stenographer takes their names and all that,
and shows them into Mr. Gately’s office.”</p>
<p>As Norah spoke she went on to the second
room. Oblivious to its grandeur and luxury, she
gave swift, darting glances here and there and
said positively: “Of course, it was Mr. Gately who
was shot, and by a woman too!”</p>
<p>“The woman who screamed?”</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_23">[23]</div>
<p>“No: more likely not. I expect the woman who
screamed was his stenographer. I know her,—at
least, I’ve seen her. A little doll-faced jig, who
belongs about third from the end, in the chorus!
Be sure she’d scream at the pistol shot, but the
lady who fired the shot wouldn’t.”</p>
<p>“But I saw the scrimmage and it was a man
who shot.”</p>
<p>“Are you sure? That thick, clouded glass blurs
a shadow beyond recognition.”</p>
<p>“What makes you think it was a woman, then?”</p>
<p>“This,” and Norah pointed to a hatpin that lay
on the big desk.</p>
<p>It was a fine-looking pin, with a big head, but
when I was about to pick it up Norah dissuaded
me.</p>
<p>“Don’t touch it,” she warned; “you know, Mr.
Brice, we’ve really no right here and we simply
must not touch anything.”</p>
<p>“But, Norah,” I began, my common sense and
good judgment having returned to me with the
advent of human companionship, “I don’t want to
do anything wrong. If we’ve no right here, for
Heaven’s sake, let’s get out!”</p>
<p>“Yes, in a minute, but let me think what you
ought to do. And, oh, do let me take a minute
to look round!”</p>
<p>“No, girl; this is no time to satisfy your
curiosity or, to enjoy a sight of these——”</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_24">[24]</div>
<p>“Oh, I don’t mean that! But I want to see if
there isn’t some clew or some bit of evidence to
the whole thing. It is too weird! too impossible
that three people should have disappeared into
nothingness! Where are they?”</p>
<p>Norah looked in the same closets I had explored;
she drew aside window draperies and portières, she
hastily glanced under desks and tables, not so much,
I felt sure, in expectation of finding anyone, as
with a general idea of searching the place thoroughly.</p>
<p>She scrutinized the desk fittings of the stenographer.</p>
<p>“Everything of the best,” she commented, “but
very little real work done up here. I fancy these
offices of Mr. Gately’s are more for private conferences
and personal appointments than any real
business matters.”</p>
<p>“Which would account for the lady’s hatpin,”
I observed.</p>
<p>“Yes; but how did they get out? You looked
out in the hall, at once, you say?”</p>
<p>“Yes; I came quickly through these three
rooms, and then looked out into the hall at once,
and there was no elevator in sight nor could I see
anyone on the stairs.”</p>
<p>“Well, there’s not much to be seen here. I
suppose you’d better call up the bank people.
Though if they thought there was anything queer
they’d be up here by this time.”</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_25">[25]</div>
<p>I left Norah in Mr. Gately’s rooms while I went
back to my own office and called up the Puritan
Trust Company.</p>
<p>A polite voice assured me that they knew nothing
of Mr. Gately’s whereabouts at that moment,
but if I would leave a message he would ultimately
receive it.</p>
<p>So, then, I told them, in part, what had happened,
or, rather, what I believed had happened, and still
a little unconcerned, the polite man agreed to send
somebody up.</p>
<p>“Stuffy people!” I said to Norah, as I returned
to the room she was in. “They seemed to think
me officious.”</p>
<p>“I feared they would, Mr. Brice, but you had to
do it. There’s no doubt Mr. Gately left this room
in mad haste. See, here’s his personal checkbook
on his desk, and he drew a check today.”</p>
<p>“Nothing remarkable in his drawing a check,”
I observed, “but decidedly peculiar to leave his
checkbook around so carelessly. As you say,
Norah, he left in a hurry.”</p>
<p>“But how did he leave?”</p>
<p>“That’s the mystery; and I, for one, give it up.
I’m quite willing to wait until some greater brain
than mine works out the problem.”</p>
<p>“But it’s incomprehensible,” Norah went on;
“where’s Jenny?”</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_26">[26]</div>
<p>“For that matter,” I countered, “where’s Mr.
Gately? Where’s his angry visitor, male or female?
and, finally, where’s the pistol that made
the sound and smoke of which I had positive
evidence?”</p>
<p>“We may find that,” suggested Norah, hopefully.</p>
<p>But careful search failed to discover any firearms,
as it had failed to reveal the actors of the
drama.</p>
<p>Nor did the representative from the bank come
up at once. This seemed queer, I thought, and
with a sudden impulse to find out something, I
declared I was going down to the bank myself.</p>
<p>“Go on,” said Norah, “I’ll stay here, for I must
know what they find out when they do come.”</p>
<p>I went out into the hall and pushed the “Down”
button of the elevator.</p>
<p>“Be careful,” Norah warned me, as the car was
heard ascending, “say very little, Mr. Brice,
except to the proper authorities. This may be a
terrible thing, and you mustn’t get mixed up in it
until you know more about it. You were not only
the first to discover the disappearance,—but you
and I are apparently the only ones in this corridor
who know of it yet, we may be——”</p>
<p>“Suspected of the abduction of Amos Gately!
Hardly! Don’t let your detective instinct run
away with you Norah!”</p>
<p>And then the elevator door slid open and I got
into the car.</p>
<div class="pb" id="Page_27">[27]</div>
<div style="break-after:column;"></div><br />